Library / Fantastic Fables

The Discontented Malefactor

A fable by Ambrose Bierce

Satire for older readers

Save
The Discontented Malefactor

A judge, having sentenced a malefactor to the penitentiary, was proceeding to explain the disadvantages of crime and the benefits of reformation.

"Your Honor," said the malefactor, interrupting, "would you be kind enough to alter my punishment to ten years in the penitentiary and nothing else?"

"Why," replied the judge, surprised, "I have given you only three years!"

"Yes, I know," the malefactor admitted. "Three years' imprisonment and the preaching. If you please, I would like to commute the preaching."

The moral
Some individuals may prefer punishment over the moral lessons that come with it, highlighting a resistance to personal reform and the value of accountability.

Discussion questions

  1. Why do you think the Malefactor prefers punishment without moral lessons?
  2. How does the story illustrate the challenges of personal reform?
  3. In what ways can moral stories, like this one, influence our decision-making in real life?

Advertisement

Read it in another language

Good night.

Tomorrow night: The Fox and the Crane