Master Hakuin Ekaku was a pillar of Zen who sought to guide his pupils beyond the traps of the intellect. To his students, he would often pose a riddle that seemed impossible: 'You can hear the sound of two hands clapping. Now show me the sound of one hand.' A young student, eager to prove his merit, spent weeks contemplating the master's words. He returned with the sound of wind, but Hakuin shook his head. He returned with the sound of a dripping tap, then the chirp of a cricket, and then absolute silence. Each time, Hakuin rejected the answer, telling him it was still a sound heard with the ears. Finally, the student realized that the 'sound' was not an external noise to be heard, but a state of being to be experienced. By moving beyond dualistic thought—beyond the distinction of sound and silence—the student grasped the essence of the void, finally understanding the soundless sound of one hand.
True wisdom and enlightenment are found by transcending logical, dualistic thinking to experience the essence of reality directly.
Questions about this story
What is the moral of Hakuin's One Hand?
The moral is that spiritual truth cannot be found through intellectual logic or physical senses. It requires one to transcend dualistic thinking to find unity and direct experience.
Who was Master Hakuin?
Hakuin Ekaku was one of the most influential Japanese Zen Buddhist masters, known for revitalizing the Rinzai school and creating the 'one hand' koan.
What is a Zen koan?
A koan is a paradoxical anecdote or riddle used in Zen Buddhism to demonstrate the inadequacy of logical reasoning and to provoke enlightenment.
Is there a 'correct' answer to the sound of one hand clapping?
There is no verbal or physical answer that is 'correct.' The goal is for the student to reach a specific state of non-dual consciousness where the question itself disappears.
Advertisement
Good night.
